
Yes, my dog chose my makeup. Everyone always seems to get excited when Hugo features in a post, so this post is all about him. I’ve wanted to do this for a while now, but I wasn’t too sure how to go about it.
You may have seen this video on YouTube a lot this year, I know most people film this then do something like put three options down with food/ treats next to them and let their dogs run to them and pick the first product they eat next to as the one they chose. Here’s the thing, my dog would not co-operate with that kind of game at all. He’d take one look at them, turn away and go back to sleep, leaving the food for later.

How we did this
I wanted to accommodate the little man’s needs, so I brought my products to him while he was lounging on his favourite seat. Three products for each category were placed in front of him, he’d lift his head to see what I was doing then I’d pick the product he was looking at/ had his head closest too when he tried to go back to sleep and ignore me.


The only exception was lip liners, he was clearly getting sick of me disturbing him, so I held three in front of him and chose the one he sniffed first.
Oh and I’m not copping out, we’re doing a full face.
Cruelty Free?
I mentioned in a post earlier this year that I’m no longer buying new products that aren’t CF, but I am allowing myself to repurchase some old favourites that aren’t CF if I can’t find a CF alternative I love as much. And obviously, I still have a lot of older products to use up. So, many of the products in this post aren’t cruelty free, please don’t assume that everything because you’re used to reading vegan friendly content here.
My Dog Chose My Makeup – The Products
The products I presented him with will be listed, the one he chose will be in bold.
Foundation
- Laura Mercier Flawless Fusion – 1N1 (not CF)
- Makeup Forever Water Blend – Y215 (not CF)
- Rimmel Wake Me Up – Light Porcelain (not CF)
I would have been happy with any of these but Water Blend would have been my first choice. The one he picked is the most matte (I have dry skin and it’s November in northern England) and it’s the darkest one. But I do like the formula, so no major issues here.

Concealer
- Too Faced Born This Way – Fairest (vegan)
- Colourpop Pretty Fresh – 05w (CF)
- XX Revolution – C0.05 (vegan)
I wanted either the Too Faced or the Revolution so I’m happy, and this concealer is a great match for me so hopefully, I can balance out the dark foundation a little bit.
Blush
- Benefit Gold Rush (not CF)
- Colourpop Blush Stix – Aloha (vegan)
- Rimmel Moisture Renew Lipstick – Notting Hill Nude (discontinued, not CF)
At the start of this, I would have said I wanted either of the cream products. However, the foundation he picked doesn’t always wear well with creams over it, so he actually picked the right one for his base in the end. Good boy, Hugo.
Contour
- Illamasqua Cream Pigment – Hollow (CF)
- Benefit Hoola Quickie Contour (Not CF)
- NYX HD blush – Taupe (CF)
Illamasqua please please please. Or maybe not. I’m glad he didn’t pick the powder. But the Benefit one is way too dark for me so I have to use this very lightly and under my foundation rather than on top. And it’s too warm for someone with my skin tone to contour with, so this is going to be more of a sun kissed bronze than a suck the cheekbones in kind of situation.
Highlight
- Becca Shimmering Skin Perfector – Pearl (Vegan)
- Wet n Wild Megaglow Highlighting Powder – Blossom Glow (Vegan)
- Bali Body Highlighting Stick – Moonlit (Vegan)
When it comes to highlighter, Becca pearl is always the right answer for me. I like all of these ones, but the Wet n Wild is cooler toned and he’s going for a warmer look so far. The Bali Body one is warmer, but as I said, this foundation and liquids/ creams don’t always work well. So, he picked my favourite highlighter ever, and the best one for his look so far. CLEVER BOY.
Eyeshadow Palette
- By Beauty Bay – Fiery 16 pan (Vegan)
- Too Faced Natural Matte (CF)
- Colorpop Flutter by (CF)
Again, at the starting point, I would have been happy with any of them. But as my base is going to be warmer than I’d usually wear it, I would have preferred either the Beauty Bay or Too Faced option. No complaints about his choice.
Oh, and when I told my mother about this she asked if he placed his head in the same place every time. No, I couldn’t place my favourite in a certain spot so he’d pick it. Trust me, I tried.

Eyeliner
For eyeliner I did it a little differently, I gave him the option of a shadow from his chosen palette, a pencil or a gel.
- Palette (Vegan)
- Pencil (Not CF)
- Gel/ Bobbi Brown Caviar Ink (Not CF)
I didn’t really want the black pencil as I prefer brown liner, but any would have been fine. He chose well though.
Brows
This was pretty simple; these three products came together in a set. All three are the same shade so he can’t screw me over and pick something black (I’m a 2 if anyone is wondering), he just has to pick my product.
- Goof Proof
- Precisely, My Brow
- Gimme Brow
It was at this moment I wished we’d never started. I love both of the pencil options I gave him, but I hate Gimme Brow alone. I’m not blessed naturally in the brow department and find fibre gels like that don’t really work for me unless I already have lightly filled brows. I can’t just do a few strokes of this and call it a day. He was doing SO well, then he picked the one product in this whole post that I really didn’t want.
Lipstick
- Tom Ford – Scarlett Rouge (Not CF)
- Sephora Cream Lip Stain – 01 Always Red (Not CF)
- Charlotte Tilbury Kissing Lipstick – Stoned Rose (CF)
I mean, he had two cool toned reds and one slightly warmer toned neutral colour. And he’s picked a warm base, a warm eye, and the warmer lipstick? Okay, big man, I see you have a vision here.
Lipliner
Time for the moment of truth, he had two red and a neutral, one to match each of the lipsticks. As you know, he picked the neutral lipstick. This is the point where things could go very wrong for me.
- Chanel Le Crayon Levres – 184 (Not CF)
- Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheat – Kiss ‘n’ Tell (CF)
- Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheat – Pillow Talk (CF)
GOOD BOY. I know the odds were against me there and people probably think I’m making this up but I swear he sniffed Pillow Talk, then tried to lick it, then his participation in this post swiftly ended.
The final look
I have a confession, I got a phone call while I was halfway through my makeup and realised that I had to actually leave my house that afternoon after I’d finished my look for this post. I didn’t want to have to redo my brows, so I skipped them completely and did them after I’d taken my photos. Sorry, Hugo.

This is quite different from anything I’d usually go for, but I’m so glad he actually picked a tonal look with products that work well together. I hated it at first, but I think that’s because of the lack of brows, and thought I looked a bit odd fully done without them. A high neck hides the sins of his foundation choices.
Overall, I think I’m happy with this?
How do you guys think he did? I think he’s a genius.
Until next time,
Sophie
Oh my gosh this is absolutely hilarious and brilliant idea! I’d love to do this with my cat…
He made good choices, what a fun idea. I’m not great at applying makeup. What is a good foundation to buy that provides good coverage? Thanks
This is such a great idea. Hugo is so adorable and made great choices.
This was such a fun post idea! I have seen a few YouTube videos doing this and it looks so fun. I love the look Hugo picked for you, the lipstick shade is gorgeous! X
Haha this is cute!! I am not sure I can tempt my cats into doing something similar! You’d dog is adorable!!
I absolutely love this idea, it’s so cute. I think Hugo did amazing! I love the end look! I kind of want to try this out with my family cat but I can’t imagine he will want to join in, he only likes to sleep and eat and I can see him getting very fed up with me very quickly haha. xx
Omg, this is soooo cooool! I love your idea about letting your dog to choose your make-up! And don’t worry, you look wonderful!
I think your dog did very well and chose some great makeup products for you to use! This is such a fun and creative idea for a post, I don’t think my cat would be so willing to choose my makeup look! x
Lucy | http://www.lucymary.co.uk
This is such a cute idea! And I love the final look of your makeup xx
http://www.dellalovesnutella.co.uk/
Omg this is so cute!
This bit ‘I wanted to accommodate the little man’s needs, so I brought my products to him while he was lounging on his favourite seat.’ accommodate his needs haha
Hayley || hayleyxmartin
You look amazing and I love that Hugo played a part in this (he’s very cute BTW). A fun post! Thanks for sharing.
What a fun challenge! I really loved the final look. How cute us your pup!
xoxo
Lovely
http://www.mynameislovely.com
What an absolutely adorable idea, and your pup picked such good products! Love the final look, your good boy has taste!
This is so fun. Your make up looks great, and how cute is your dog.
https://www.ninakobi.com/
He did a marvelous job of it too. Lookin’ good.
This is absolutely amazing. I love this idea. Also, the eye shadow palette is just wow.
I absolutely love the final look. That lipstick is gorgeous! Such a fun idea and your little pup is super cute I’d say he did good on this look ❤️
The makeup looked turned out great! 🙂 Your dog has good taste. hahaha
~ Brittany
https://mindbeautysimplicity.wordpress.com
Oh my god I loved this concept! I agree, he’s a genius. I actually really love the look x
https://www.femaleoriginal.com
Reading this made me chuckle! I love challenges and little things like a dog choosing make-up; I think it is a great way to put together a look you might never try. I actually really love the colors; the lipstick compliments your eyes and hair.
Congratulations to Hugo! 🙂
I don’t think either of my dogs would be able to do this, they’d probably step on everything and break them! He did do very well though x
Emily | emiliamarlowe.co.uk
I really enjoyed reading all the way through your post. You have such an amazing doggie and he is so adorable too!!
Oh this is the cutest makeup post ever! What a great idea, I don’t think I could get my dog to stick around long enough to keep picking haha. I have to say I think he did quite well!
Soph – https://sophhearts.com x
Your dog is so cute and this is such a cool idea. I like products that you use, Laura Mercier foundation is amazing, as well as you makeup look.
New Post – https://www.exclusivebeautydiary.com/2020/11/ysl-black-opium-eau-de-parfum.html
Fun post! I think my rabbit would chew my makeup so not going to try this. It’s so interesting to do this though because you end up with some great looks in the end that you never would have gone for yourself.
Your dog is adorable! He’s the perfect little makeup artist! If I had a dog, I’d probably get him/her to pick what book I should read or what show I should watch. My cat would have just walked off! Haha!
I love love love this idea! Your dog is so cute and I really like the final makeup look!! x
This is so fun! And I’m glad it’s not just me who’s dog falls asleep on them!
Katie | katieemmabeauty.com
Love this blog post! Great choice of products and I love the final look! Thank you for sharing this!
Looks to me like he did a pretty good job in picking products that work together well! I really love that lip colour on you – it really suits you. I might have to take inspiration from your post and do something similar. It might encourage me to try out some products and combinations that I haven’t tried in a while.
This is such a fun post. Hugo is super cute. And I think he did a great job. Love that lipstick!!!
That’s so cute Hugo picked out your makeup! I love your final makeup look so I think he did pretty well!
That is the blog post title of dreams, there’s NO WAY I’m not going to click through! I think Hugo did a stellar job, your make up looks gorgeous. OK, it might not be a look you’d normally go for but it’s good to try new things and I hope you’ll let him choose for you again – well done, Hugo, you get all the treats! xx
Aww what a cute idea! ☺️
I love the final look as well so the choices were perfect!
Love Lozza x
http://girlygabble.com
What a great idea and Hugo definitely has a budding career as a make-up artist after this! Love the look that he chose too, the lipstick shade is gorgeous.
Thanks for sharing!
Aimsy xoxo
https://www.aimsysantics.co.uk
Awww such a great idea and Hugo chose well and he is soooooo cute. You are looking absolutely beautiful in this look Sophie.
Via | https://glossnglitters.com
What a cute blog post idea. The final outcome came out beautiful 🙂
https://www.chicnpink.com
I adore that wet n wild highlighter! x
http://www.themakeupaficionado.com